MR_SLIN
- Comp MM doesn't have a good ruleset and doesn't create quality games
True - but if no one uses the system, it's not likely to ever get fixed, as the Devs will just assume it's not a popular system and any changes to it could just be a waste of time. Using it frequently and submitting feedback daily is more likely to convince them that it is a valued feature, and worth the time and effort to improve.
MR_SLIN
- TF2Center/Stadium makes no attempt to balance Pugs
TF2 Center actually has a balancing system (I think they refer to them as Advanced lobbies), which resorts both teams when both are full. I'm not sure how good it is at actually balancing teams, but it's not very popular. A lot of people like to play lobbies with friends, and that obviously doesn't guarantee you get the team or players you want.
MR_SLIN
- PugChamp is great for high-level gameplay but doesn't allow for more than three pugs to be run at once
- MixChamp is great for medium-level gameplay but starts immediately when all 12 roles are filled, so it doesn't really suit high-level pugs
After talking with someone I'm changing my comment on PugChamp. I thought the limit of three pugs at a time is due to the fact there are only 3 servers (which is the case), but, there's also an issue that not many people want to captain or play medic. One of the problems with the captain system, that I didn't see mentioned is that when there's a really good player captaining, it means any other potential captains also have to be really good - otherwise their team is at a disadvantage from the start. For instance, if a high level player like b4nny is a captain, and I wanted to captain against that person (keep in mind I'm considerably lower level), no matter how good a player I pick as my first choice, his team gets him automatically - in addition to whichever good players he picks. So I drag my own team down if I choose to captain against a better player, which deters me from captaining in this type of scenario.
As for MixChamp, another problem is that it's hard to find folks willing to play Medic at that level (the less cohesion a team has, the more the medic will suffer for it), and there's also only one server for MixChamp, so only one game can be active at a time. :(