Random thoughts from a really low level player..
Sideshow's post (#149) makes the most sense here because it addresses the reality of MM. With no class limits, MM would meet thousands of angry pubbers intending to wreck havoc in a format that left them out.
I wish everyone could remember that TF2 is played daily by tens of thousands of players and the vast majority of these do not play 6s. I avidly support the desire to establish TF2 as a legitimate e-sport for elite players; I just don't agree with MM being the tool to initiate it.
Honestly, I'd like to throw the dictionary at everyone who uses the word "meta." Or maybe not. Meta means making reference to oneself and indeed, those using it are referring to a minute fraction of the TF2 population.
Leaving out half the classes and most of the maps isn't going to force players to adopt new classes and play styles, because many find the 6s format less exciting to play. It already isn't...the majority of us low level players simply aren't participating because we find it boring. What we were once truly excited for...now, it's just MEH. Again, that's tens of thousands of players rejecting MM, which perhaps was the point all along? Weed out the riff-raff?
I apologize for getting off-topic here. The main thing I wanted to say was this: I agree with much of what Stabby and Dane have said on the topic of MM. I think this discussion can be had without the personal attacks. Gaaaaaaaa, it's like Trickle-Down Trump. I've read so many thoughtful, interesting posts here and kudos to those willing to address these concerns in a respectful manner. Whether or not your message gets heard relies on how you deliver it. Shitty comments about players most of us respect or admire don't help.