SpaceCadetWhat I find hard to grasp are the decisions made by the league. They seem to change often depending on the situation. There is also no consistency with upholding rules and simply ignoring other established rules. All decisions seem to be spur-of-the-moment actions and are rarely backed-up by good reasoning.
The most recent case was this season in IM and Faint Gaming. Refer to Post #182 in the IM happenings thread below:
http://www.teamfortress.tv/47564/esea-season-28-intermediate-happenings-discussion/?page=7
That said, I find it hard to understand how and why the league is deciding to only now uphold a rule they never cared about in the past and use it to penalize players. The example above was a clear situation of the league not playing by the rules, so where is that penalty? If that can be explained, then the league has my support.
Speaking for just myself, I like the move-up rule because sandbagging is always a fucking joke and the players doing it over and over don't give a shit about anyone but themselves and their little pack of friends. That aside, what I want is the league to stop catering to these individuals/groups and just uphold the rules regardless of who it impacts. If rules are dumb, then change them to fit the times/situations and stick by them. The worst thing an admin can do is ignore a rule when it isn't convenient and then uphold a rule just because they feel like it all of a sudden.
in terms of FAINT playing in IM this season, they did literally nothing against the rules and in fact I was more upset about popo still playing IM after winning it with an identical roster than FAINT playing, their team had gaps and in the past teams like that have not always won (which also seemed to be true this season). as for them not being moved out for violating the roster rule, Im not sure I can speak on it because I don't know the exact details but as far as Im concerned they deserved to be there more than popo did.
regarding the enforcement of the rule, my understanding is that at the beginning of the season ESEA announced new roster move up rules for the entire league, not just TF2. Sandbagging is a problem in TF2 but its also been made clear its a problem in CSGO as well and they created more strict guidelines this season specifically for CSGO, but as we all know the state that TF2 is in, whatever happens in ESEA CSGO must also have TF2 follow suit.
Our main admin is tri and trust me when I say he more than anyone wants invite to succeed and wants the appropriate teams to move up, this is why this thread is even happening in the first place. Unfortunately he is not the end all of decisions even for TF2, he has to go through a board and other admins to get any change approved at all, and currently hes just trying to enforce the new rules put in place for him.