@tsc: I don't think anyone is blaming you for this.
Also friendly reminder that RGL was founded to promote different rulesets and formats, not to preserve 6s. Betting on RGL to prevent a fracturing of the TF2 scene is making the fox guard the henhouse.
I mean sigafoo did listen to feedback, but if the one thing everyone could at least somewhat agree on, the global whitelist, unlike pretty much everything else like league format, maps and timelimits, was to be thrown out of the window it's clear where he wants to go with this.
It's like putting Iran in charge of enforcing the nuclear non-proliferation treaty. It might work, but I really wouldn't recommend it if there's any other option.
I know NA is obsessed with having a paid league and endured all the shit ESEA pulled to keep it but at this point you might have to sacrifice something. What's more important, having a 6s league that will stay a 6s league with the rules you want even if it's free (you can still donate what you would've paid in fees to the prizepool) or having a paid league that may or may not force unpopular ruleset changes, just for the sake of having a paid league? I mean what's the downside of the free league?
I just don't see any advantage to RGL over NACL other than sigafoo throwing money at it. But that's neither guaranteed in the long term nor would I trust his motives (see early announcement and season start). He who pays the piper calls the tune. And I don't think he wants the tune you want.