I actually played faceit before tf2pl came in and the games were decent most of the time(when you wouldn't get matched[your team is all randoms,yes] against ex-prem players and their stacks,looking at you jackylegs).
But there always has been times where you either get the stronger player on his main + 2 dudes that know how to position themselves/doing things by the book and you win
Or you get either 1 sniper main permaoffclassing spamming allchat/gamers fresh out of casual and lose anyway,it's how their system works which doesn't seem to get fixed unless you straightup start excluding certain people from playing.
And regarding fatkids,this is still based on the perception of the captain at the time and doesn't always reflect the state of leaderboard.If for the EU,raymon gets fatkidded - imagine the incentives for the other people to add up.It's still all relative someone is going to fit more into a certain draft composition,look like an official team and viceversa
With the right teams,a player could grow and there won't be much difference in comparison with the other choices.You may get owned but you help him stand up and guide him in the right direction. By the proper maincalling,he would get better results(of course it depends on the person).It's naive to expect him to do well with 0 communication and complete indifference. If you don't think that someone has the necessary skills to play in the comp environment then give him a hand instead of being a condescending douchebag.
And still picking your best team doesn't guarantee a victory,lots of things can go wrong if your opposing team is of a nice quality. As kev already mentioned before,there is a significant advantage if you pick first/or second on pugchamp that can throw balanced games out of the window.

They are not a team
What Are They Doing?
What are these bots?
are you dumb?

You don't deserve
Worthless
Cocky retard
Pure accident(after getting jumped by the enemy soldier)
X(being any player at the moment)playing the game of his life

sukamon(memes aside)
And the evolution of that flying digimon of the youngest boy in the group

6s players acting entitled again and telling what you should do and what you shouldn't.
Definitely didn't see this one coming

Classic etf2l admins in action

You pick those soldiers and then pray that benny beam scout is going to 1v5 them?

Permanent sniper for the memes and lose anyway
Permanent pyro
ESEA Highlander Season 27(Sponsored by froyotech)

highfive

I want to know what's going on in the mind of the people that decided to unironically cut dagger

Prolands(nauseating)
Product(permanent sniper from both teams with meme instakills hype)

https://clips.twitch.tv/CrazyEphemeralHummingbirdGingerPower

http://steamcommunity.com/id/nwaoo

Projecting much?