If not for the inconsistency with bans, this league would be pretty great. It's understandable that the community would chose to give RGL a chance, none of the ban cringe has happened to me so I've enjoyed my experience thus far. I think that if admins got together and wrote up a big document detailing punishments for specific offences, they'd all be on the same page and things would be smooth sailing.
If player commits x offence then punishment is x. No gray area/admin relationship bullshit, easy as that.