quintoshClarkSo if that's the case you can easily go back and check why Odin was not banned for the badwater demo.
AC investigations operate on the premise of the player being innocent, it is not their job to prove why someone didn't cheat. This is something AC holds to the highest standard so what you are asking for does not exist per se. Brian told you that there is no trace of that match being investigated, whether that never happened or the documentation for it is gone, no one can tell you with 100% certainty and you've been told as much already. Samus told you that there wasn't a time where everyone but one person was in favour of a ban for Odin and I don't remember such a thing happening either. Me (and others) have personally established that the AC staff shouldn't be a mere 3 people anymore and that not everyone has to agree with each other or cast their verdict for something to happen as this has caused cases to stall (due to reasons mentioned already), and this procedure was established long before that match was played.
Why you would bring up Discord is also beyond me. There is no ban-voting process happening there and every investigation is documented thoroughly in detail on the forums. The Discord is limited to general discussions, chit-chat, questions and ping reminders to look at cases and to vote in the forum threads or calls to archive - any kind of reviews for specific demos would not be written on Discord.
What would due process to re-open (or open, if the original case was never properly submitted) the 2019 case look like? I know that Brian said they already have a lot of cases open right now, but surely you can't just sweep it under the rug, and be like "welp, it happened a long time ago + ratio + cope", given the response from the community?
P.S. I know that you're not an active AC admin anymore, quintosh, and might not have an answer to this question, but given how so many admins and ex-admins came in full force in this thread, you obviously care enough to see this case get resolved.