After taking some time to cool down (I normally get super defensive and don't back down no matter what), I really was in the wrong here. My initial thoughts going through this conversation was that the 2 players were going to need 1 month of freemium just to start off. I skew my words for this job in certain situation but this is actually one of those times it really was a misunderstanding. Either way, I'm going to pay for the leader and the 2 members who were thinking of joining out my own pocket. I clarified with the other teams that I gave freemium for only 2 months but I must have been in a rush with this one and forgot (If not, expect more threads). Anyways, I'll pm you in the morning for the 3 profiles.
TLDR; I fucked up, I guess live and learn ... and pay.