harbleujust some insight on the match, it looks like bote's starting demo won't be here tonight and instead of using one of their 10 backups they have on the roster they want to use a ringer instead. i normally have no issue allowing ringers regular season, but with that many backups and having had a whole season to have coverage for all classes i chose to deny them one. they apparently didn't even try asking their backups before trying to get a ringer instead, whats the point of having backups if you don't even try to use them? hopefully its still a good match and whoever they have show up ends up playing well.
I don't know if you follow other Highlander teams very closely given the amount of security you have starting on mTs for years now, but finding a demoman who is able to compete at the top of Platinum yet is also willing to learn and dedicate to the nuances of Highlander is incredibly difficult for teams outside of the top. It's the largest hurdle for newer teams in Platinum that slow them down from reaching the upper parts of the division despite having very talented players on other classes. I can't emphasize this enough.
I respect your decision to deny their ringer, but given how class-specific Highlander is not all of those backups may actually play demo and since there is a huge expectation for a demo's performance at the top of Platinum, I wouldn't have been surprised if all 10 of those backups fell a little short of that. If their best bet for the team after Muma was having Freestate off-class (who is a great demo but it's not his best class), then I also hope that gives you a better picture of how badly top tier demo mains are wanted in Highlander but are in short supply. I think that allowing the ringer would have been a more fair decision towards bote's chances in playoffs.