JwI have no intention of ever boarding a train, so I shouldn't have to pay for it.
"I have no intention of ever going to school, so I shouldn't have to pay for it."
You're also paying for a lot of federal highways you'll never use, just like others will pay for highways they won't use. It evens out.
#40
If you want the actual reasons why it can't happen, it's very simple:
Step 1: Try and fail to regulate the railway companies into some semblance of usefulness, because if they are allowed to abandon any route that is mildly unprofitable or even just not profitable enough, and price gouge on any route with no competition, the system will quickly implode.
Step 2: Wait until everyone is bankrupt before stepping in.
Step 3: Consolidate that mess into a quasi-public corporation and operate it as for-profit. Hint: It was never going to become profitable over night.
Step 4: Let the real estate market become a cancerous price inflation machine because "the stock market demands it"
Step 5: You have now ensured that no one can ever build a HSR network anywhere near a population center without paying ridiculous sums for just the land, and that the only one still in the business of passenger railway will never have any money to spare to even consider it.
For comparison, here's a look at Spain:
The most expensive project is going to cost 12.5 billion euros, which works out to a bit under 25 million USD per mile at current exchange rates.
The last bit towards the Pyrenees (not even in the mountains, just to reach them) cost them 52 million USD per mile. The actual mountain part ended up slightly cheaper at 47 million.
They did it anyway, because connecting the rest of the European HSR network was worth it.
Yes, on other routes it's more around 20 million, but it's still a lot. The trick is to not whine about it and build it anyway.
#41
Yes, HSR is more of a midrange thing. If you need to travel 1000 miles you'd need a maglev or hyperloop or something else to come closer to the speeds of a plane.
Time for boarding/security checks, start, landing and all that even out with the lower speed of a train compared to a plane, so the two real advantages of HSR are that you can put a train station right in the middle of a city and even multiple, which drastically cuts down on detours to and from airports, and the sheer volume you can push through.
Both are only really relevant for reasonably densely populated regions, not for a section of a cross-continental route through North Dakota.