Upvote Upvoted 2 Downvote Downvoted
1 2
do you think closed captions are overpowered?
1
#1
1 Frags +

slash gives you an unfair advantage?

opinions are split between 'gives you an advantage and you know who is hurt or buffed without looking at them' and 'it doesn't do anything and is unnecessary'

your thoughts?

slash gives you an unfair advantage?

opinions are split between 'gives you an advantage and you know who is hurt or buffed without looking at them' and 'it doesn't do anything and is unnecessary'

your thoughts?
2
#2
3 Frags +

I'd tell you if I could fucking figure out how to install it

on a related note, free craft hat for anyone who helps me in that regard <3

I'd tell you if I could fucking figure out how to install it

on a related note, free craft hat for anyone who helps me in that regard <3
3
#3
10 Frags +

It's not an unfair advantage, anyone can use it.

It's not an unfair advantage, anyone can use it.
4
#4
11 Frags +

Personally I think it takes you away from the game and just gives you one more thing to focus on. Also you could always bump up your volume and just hear the calls instead of reading captions.

Personally I think it takes you away from the game and just gives you one more thing to focus on. Also you could always bump up your volume and just hear the calls instead of reading captions.
5
#5
27 Frags +
liasIt's not an unfair advantage, anyone can use it.

by that mentality, wouldn't openplugin not be an unfair advantage?

[quote=lias]It's not an unfair advantage, anyone can use it.[/quote]

by that mentality, wouldn't openplugin not be an unfair advantage?
6
#6
4 Frags +
SnowyI'd tell you if I could fucking figure out how to install it

on a related note, free craft hat for anyone who helps me in that regard <3

you should just be able to drag and drop closecaption_english.dat and closecaption_english.txt into your hud's resource folder then add closecaption 1 into console

[quote=Snowy]I'd tell you if I could fucking figure out how to install it

on a related note, free craft hat for anyone who helps me in that regard <3[/quote]
you should just be able to drag and drop closecaption_english.dat and closecaption_english.txt into your hud's resource folder then add closecaption 1 into console
7
#7
10 Frags +

It's part of the game.

It's part of the game.
8
#8
3 Frags +
SnowyI'd tell you if I could fucking figure out how to install it

on a related note, free craft hat for anyone who helps me in that regard <3

Snowy, check out this guide:

http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=167785751#124654

[quote=Snowy]
I'd tell you if I could fucking figure out how to install it

on a related note, free craft hat for anyone who helps me in that regard <3[/quote]

Snowy, check out this guide:

http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=167785751#124654
9
#9
0 Frags +
SBARROHOTTOPICliasIt's not an unfair advantage, anyone can use it.
by that mentality, wouldn't openplugin not be an unfair advantage?

Project-7 public isnt an unfair advantage

[quote=SBARROHOTTOPIC][quote=lias]It's not an unfair advantage, anyone can use it.[/quote]

by that mentality, wouldn't openplugin not be an unfair advantage?[/quote]
Project-7 public isnt an unfair advantage
10
#10
9 Frags +

It's no different than using a custom HUD. Although alot of the information it displays isn't that helpful as the range on the closed captions isnt that far.

It's no different than using a custom HUD. Although alot of the information it displays isn't that helpful as the range on the closed captions isnt that far.
11
#11
9 Frags +

not really, i think its confusing.

not really, i think its confusing.
12
#12
3 Frags +

Not really. I use them, but 90% of the time I forget about them completely. That and it only seems to work about half the time.

Not really. I use them, but 90% of the time I forget about them completely. That and it only seems to work about half the time.
13
#13
0 Frags +
aresSnowyI'd tell you if I could fucking figure out how to install it

on a related note, free craft hat for anyone who helps me in that regard <3

Snowy, check out this guide:

http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=167785751#124654

I'm reasonably confident I followed those instructions properly, but my game just crashes whenever I choose a class.

I'll survive without them. Looks really cool though.

[quote=ares][quote=Snowy]
I'd tell you if I could fucking figure out how to install it

on a related note, free craft hat for anyone who helps me in that regard <3[/quote]

Snowy, check out this guide:

http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=167785751#124654[/quote]

I'm reasonably confident I followed those instructions properly, but my game just crashes whenever I choose a class.

I'll survive without them. Looks really cool though.
14
#14
4 Frags +
SBARROHOTTOPICliasIt's not an unfair advantage, anyone can use it.
by that mentality, wouldn't openplugin not be an unfair advantage?

it is when they made a specific patch to warn people they were going to get vacbanned if they continued using it lol

[quote=SBARROHOTTOPIC][quote=lias]It's not an unfair advantage, anyone can use it.[/quote]

by that mentality, wouldn't openplugin not be an unfair advantage?[/quote]
it is when they made a specific patch to warn people they were going to get vacbanned if they continued using it lol
15
#15
-22 Frags +

http://www.ugcleague.com/players_page.cfm?player_id=76561198025368443

http://www.ugcleague.com/players_page.cfm?player_id=76561198025368443
16
#16
7 Frags +

while the advantage might be of a different magnitude, it's the same principle of colorblind mode putting a jarate icon above their head vs just dousing them in piss. it's a feature that came with the game and i think it's fine to take advantage of it

while the advantage might be of a different magnitude, it's the same principle of colorblind mode putting a jarate icon above their head vs just dousing them in piss. it's a feature that came with the game and i think it's fine to take advantage of it
17
#17
5 Frags +

If it's op then why do so few people use it?

If it's op then why do so few people use it?
18
#18
4 Frags +
JohnMilterhttp://www.ugcleague.com/players_page.cfm?player_id=76561198025368443

YA GOT ME

nixnytewhile the advantage might be of a different magnitude, it's the same principle of colorblind mode putting a jarate icon above their head vs just dousing them in piss. it's a feature that came with the game and i think it's fine to take advantage of itliasIt's not an unfair advantage, anyone can use it.wareyaIt's part of the game.

I should clarify that I made this thread because my friend in mumble was saying how its unfair because it gives an advantage over people who don't use it. I think it's comparable to a HUD with bigger damage numbers or better targetids, just a better way of giving information that you could pretty much already have.

The argument against this was that the 'range is too large' and you get the information for practically free, without peeking. It was also brought up that you shouldn't have to download something to be better than another player (but again, this is kinda similar to what huds are).

I'm just curious to see what people think because 32hz was too afraid to make this thread himself

[quote=JohnMilter]http://www.ugcleague.com/players_page.cfm?player_id=76561198025368443[/quote]

YA GOT ME

[quote=nixnyte]while the advantage might be of a different magnitude, it's the same principle of colorblind mode putting a jarate icon above their head vs just dousing them in piss. it's a feature that came with the game and i think it's fine to take advantage of it[/quote]
[quote=lias]It's not an unfair advantage, anyone can use it.[/quote]
[quote=wareya]It's part of the game.[/quote]

I should clarify that I made this thread because my friend in mumble was saying how its unfair because it gives an advantage over people who don't use it. I think it's comparable to a HUD with bigger damage numbers or better targetids, just a better way of giving information that you could pretty much already have.

The argument against this was that the 'range is too large' and you get the information for practically free, without peeking. It was also brought up that you shouldn't have to download something to be better than another player (but again, this is kinda similar to what huds are).

I'm just curious to see what people think [s]because 32hz was too afraid to make this thread himself[/s]
19
#19
2 Frags +

if you put some effort into listening to the ingame sound, you can usually hear anything the closed captions would tell you that's still mildly important.

if you put some effort into listening to the ingame sound, you can usually hear anything the closed captions would tell you that's still mildly important.
20
#20
-18 Frags +

im

32hz

im

32hz
21
#21
-18 Frags +

so

32hz

so

32hz
22
#22
-18 Frags +

sorry

32hz

sorry

32hz
23
#23
2 Frags +

Closed captions aren't completely "reliable". Sure it says "Medic masked call!" or "Medic called!/has uber!" or whatever, but that doesn't mean it's true. It just means the medic said that, and anything the closed captions pick up you can always hear. "Soldier's hurt!" is also another example. Your teammates can easily call that out if you don't already hear the grunt.

Personally, I just find it to be another distraction on the field, I mean after all you DO have to LOOK at it, and those moments can mean missing a shot or not.

Overall, no harm no foul in using it. It's all preference. Some benefit a lot from it while others don't like it for whatever reason. Bottom line, in my opinion, it's not "overpowered"

Closed captions aren't completely "reliable". Sure it says "Medic masked call!" or "Medic called!/has uber!" or whatever, but that doesn't mean it's true. It just means the medic said that, and anything the closed captions pick up you can always hear. "Soldier's hurt!" is also another example. Your teammates can easily call that out if you don't already hear the grunt.

Personally, I just find it to be another distraction on the field, I mean after all you DO have to LOOK at it, and those moments can mean missing a shot or not.

Overall, no harm no foul in using it. It's all preference. Some benefit a lot from it while others don't like it for whatever reason. Bottom line, in my opinion, it's not "overpowered"
24
#24
-4 Frags +

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_AfZYw9H8jA

also i never mentioned making a thread about it, you mentioned it and continued to leave mumble 15 minutes later for unknown reasons like you always do

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_AfZYw9H8jA[/youtube]

also i never mentioned making a thread about it, you mentioned it and continued to leave mumble 15 minutes later for unknown reasons like you always do
25
#25
1 Frags +
PhraktureIf it's op then why do so few people use it?

While I'm not necessarily agreeing with the notion that CC are OP, a small amount of people using something does not amount to it not being OP. That's silly logic.

[quote=Phrakture]If it's op then why do so few people use it?[/quote]

While I'm not necessarily agreeing with the notion that CC are OP, a small amount of people using something does not amount to it not being OP. That's silly logic.
26
#26
4 Frags +

OP, fuck the deaf

OP, fuck the deaf
27
#27
20 Frags +
JohnMilterhttp://www.ugcleague.com/players_page.cfm?player_id=76561198025368443

why are you such an elitist prick

[quote=JohnMilter]http://www.ugcleague.com/players_page.cfm?player_id=76561198025368443[/quote]
why are you such an elitist prick
28
#28
1 Frags +

CC has been around for years now, right? Didn't Gmang's HUD have them built in or something? Or was that a custom CC system? I don't even remember anymore it's been so long.

CC has been around for years now, right? Didn't Gmang's HUD have them built in or something? Or was that a custom CC system? I don't even remember anymore it's been so long.
29
#29
-6 Frags +

Counterthesis: Is there anyway to ban the use of closed captions. If not, than the argument if it's overpowered or considered "cheating" is irrelevant.

Counterthesis: Is there anyway to ban the use of closed captions. If not, than the argument if it's overpowered or considered "cheating" is irrelevant.
30
#30
-4 Frags +

Wait, does this display decloak?

Wait, does this display decloak?
1 2
Please sign in through STEAM to post a comment.