I don't really want to get too involved in these threads (getting ready for FITES, working almost every day up till then, etc.), but I wanna point at a few things briefly.
CEVO's problems were mainly with Admins and battling community apathy. CEVO TF2 died out in large part because the community ditched it for ESEA. When it was trying to be restarted, the admin in charge screwed things up because people were looking for a short HL tournament, it was announced as such, then he turned it into a Ladder and everyone lost interest. There is no way to prove that CEVO will be better than ESEA so asking for such proof is kind of ridiculous.
I believe we can do better (whether it's CEVO or someone else) than ESEA, but that's just my opinion.
ESEA's problems however, are at it's very top. There's been issues with admins, which happens in every league, but one of ESEA's co-owners not only was involved in criminal activity but he also was a complete dick handling the PR afterwards. LPKane's customer "service" is atrocious and has added to the feelings of discontent.
finally, here's my question for all of you who want to bail on esea: if esea never had the bitcoin scandal, would the thought of bailing on esea and switching to cevo ever crossed your mind?
Nope, but the bitcoin scandal is a prettty big deal. Besides the impact it's had on established players not wanting to continue with ESEA, the scandal has completely trashed ESEA's reputation among the general TF2 community. Threads promoting ESEA LAN on reddit were met with disdain because of the scandal. Where are the threads on reddit promoting this season's registration? I just looked and don't see anything posted by ESEA or anyone else for that matter.
ESEA threatening to close shop doesn't really help em much in my mind either. I understand business is business but if you are losing customers, you don't respond to that by threats, you respond to it by fiXing the problem and staying positive. If I recall correctly, last time they threatened to close up shop if there wasn't ____ number of teams in open, they eXacerbated the problem by eXpanding IM and not counting the teams they moved up. It struck me as dishonest...
TF2 is the only game ESEA has actually succesfully used to bring non cs-players in. Their LOL and Starcraft efforts fizzled fast. If they want to continue to have a presence outside of CounterStrike then TF2 is still their best option.
Customers left because ESEA were being dickish. Continuing to be dickish and threatening to pull the plug (even if it is the smart business decision for them), will not solve how they are viewed by most of the TF2 community.
If they don't get the numbers they need for this neXt season, I hope they make adjustments and continue for at least one more season to try and prove to the community that they are moving forward with honesty and dignity. If they do so, then perhaps the following season there will be many more people willing to sign up for their league.