Sal's.
Not even kidding, that's the name of the restaurant.
Haven't tried the other local places yet. I really should. Otherwise, I actually do like Pizza Hut (even though I work there) and Donatos. Guess Domino's is good too, their subs are pretty good.
Looking at this thread, I feel like the Midwest can't restaurant properly.
Edit: Forgot about my dad's pizza. It's probably the best pizza I've ever had- and it's for sure healthier because it isn't made in a restaurant!