pine_beetle
The point I was trying to make is that the government is not the source of all problems and people do need to take care of themselves. I'm not buying into any of the crap you are talking about I am speaking from personal experience where guys are getting payed $100 000 a year and still can barely get by. It makes no sense to me at all. Your personal experience with your mother is not anymore or less than important than my own. I can't speak in about the American system because I don't know it at all... However you are in control of your own destiny and you can make it happen. It's awesome that your mother can do that and it is unfair. If it really is that bad in America move to Canada.
The thing is that the people with salaries of $100,000 will still have access to things if they aren't free (generally people who really 'can't manage money' spend it too much, so they're quite capable of spending a bit more for an education). It seems a bit weird to talk about salaried workers in a discussion about tuition fees though, they're not normally the ones who need tertiary education because they've already had it... I do see where you're coming from a bit more now but in reality, I think, a salaried worker who just for example pisses it all away (alcohol) will still be able to have access to something as important to them as education, whereas it's just not an option for people from a financially disadvantaged background.
I'm not actually American, I'm Australian, but there are plenty of similarities in the systems. For example:
SetsulBut not everyone can win, right? So who loses? Simple: The banks. If your states goal is to maximize the banks' profit (wether or not the crippling debt for everyone who persues higher education is a bonus) then sure, go ahead.
But if your state cares more about banks than about you, I'd consider moving.
This is why our tertiary fees are growing :| it's going to cost me in the tens to hundreds of thousands over 3-5 years to go to uni and our government wants to increase it. They're also talking about forcing those with 'outstanding' student loans to 'repay' the debt even though if they haven't already then that means they've never earned enough for it to start being taken out of their salary on top of their tax (it's a bit complicated but basically they're targeting stay at home parents and the poor and disabled) so apologies if this is a bit of a raw subject for me lol
On the other hand free tuition might be one of the reasons my German penfriend didn't get offered a place at a uni this year or last year :S At least one of the advantages of our system is that basically everyone gets offered a place somewhere, it just might be at a shitty uni. If only because of the fees they can squeeze out of us.
Apologies for the ramble