seems like a cool idea.

That would be very nice since I'm looking for someone to give me tips on my play or even mentor me

yes

Cool. I just don't want to be the one required to poke the mid-high players and remind them to review demos. Hoping someone else can start the thread and take that minor burden, because it'd be neat to see.

Hopefully the demo upload section arrives soon!

i want to review demos. am i allowed to if im low/mid?

no! I forbid you from ever reviewing a demo!

okay, good. i don't want to give help that isn't wanted. thanks for letting me know before i was able to waste any time. :3

It's a forum thread, so in the rules of whatever thread gets posted, they could tell posters to request a specific skill level or higher. So if it's a total noob, I'm sure they wouldn't mind low-mid pointers.

Why would any information be worse than no information at all? Of course everybody should be able to help, it's up to the demo uploader to decide from whom he takes the advices. Hope high players help tho.

i would love this, i need it. NEEEED IT!!!

i can review open/im demos from the perspective of a roamer on a dead IM team that was destined for fame and glory. not sure if thats what you're lookin for. i am a boss of sauce, so take that as you will.

I wouldn't mind making a video every week or so of me just reviewing a demo and going over ways to fix mistakes. The only thing I'd need is a way for people to send in scrim/match POV demos.

I think a great deal of people have dropbox. They could just post the link and the reviewer can pick it up? If there is a way to message people privately it could make it where the demo wasnt public, etc.

Great idea sal <3

This would be awesome cause then everyone could learn from the mistakes and pointers and stuff you give.

Maybe they could just post an upload link in a demo-review thread, and you could download it from that?

I remember when sigma and mge did those, they were pretty neat.

I actually have a couple of soldiers that I'm trying to help right now, I'll ask them if they have any POVs and I'll try to get a video done sometime this weekend. I guess if enigma wanted to create a section people could just comment on the video and ask questions?

I was joking, just to clear that out

What would this entail? Step by step video recording, or just paragraph(s) of the demo? I'm assuming the former, but it's good to clarify.