I'd be really interested to see how the best Asian teams stack up against the Europeans, Americans and Aussies.
I'm just watching the VOD right now and I really like that asiafortress are making casts and I'd like to see more. I thought I'd give some constructive criticism for the cast.
1. Your casters sound a bit bored sometimes, they need to get excited! The casters are there to hype up the game and make it more interesting as well as tell you what's going on and imparting their knowledge of the game. They perked up a bit sometimes but they can do more. If there's not much happening or there's a pause then talk about what's happened already. In pauses especially try and analyse the situation and talk about what could happen next etc.
Actually having watched it a bit more the casters get better with time, maybe they just need to warm up a bit?
2. During the pre-game the casters were far too quiet, the pre-game time is actually really important and for the first few mins the casters were barely talking. Talk about the teams and their history a bit more. This is especially important for asiafortress as many of us outside of asia are unfamiliar with these players.
In general some casters to follow the example of include: Gecks, Sideshow, Admirable and Sigafoo
3. Your casters don't talk over each other much which is great but generally it's nice to have either:
a) A caster who deals with each event as it happens (Play by Play caster) and a caster who is the analyst who goes over what happened and why in the dead time in between events.
b) 2 casters who take it in turn to swap roles. This is not as common as a) but it works, maincall.tf used to do it to great effect and it's kinda what Arx & Beta do too but it's tricky to pull off and requires your casters to really know each other
3. The match overlay is ok but I'd make the health and name bars a bit bigger and move that down to the center of the left hand side instead of having it up in the top left. It's important information to have on the screen and I found it was a bit hard to read sometimes. I personally think TFTV's overlay has it all. It's bigger, in a better place and it also has separate bars for ubercharge which are really useful for keeping track of who has the advantage.
4. The cameraman needs to follow individual's PoV's more rather than showing a top down view. TF2 is not an easy game to follow for a viewer as there is a lot going on so it's very important the cameraman tries to catch the "highlights" of the game. Davidthewin is a great example of this especially during the i55 coverage. I don't know exactly how this is done but I know that using live logs really helps as it shows you what's happening before you see it happen on the STV due to the delay. Also as was covered by your casters, Turn your steam notification sounds off! I think I also saw your cameraman's cursor floating around on the screen during one of the granary mid fights ;)
5. The Scoreboard isn't important, don't show it during the game.
6. I personally don't like the pre-game overlay with the border. It makes the important information small. Don't be scared covering up the screen during the pre-game dm fest, it's not important and most casters actually switch away from the STV for the majority of it. Again TFTV is a great example of how an overlay could be done, especially important imo is having the scores for all the maps in the corner somewhere.
7. If there's nothing to say then go to a break. It's better to listen to music than listen to your poor casters struggling to find something to say. They end up talking about the cosmetics of the players before sunshine the poor souls.
Having said all of that, it's a promising start and I'd like to see these casts continue. Regards from the UK!