tankmanYou know whats really really interesting. We split the community in half with cevo and esea. We all got upset with esea because it did all this stupid shit but in the end they provided a service and lan albeit a shitty service it was still a service that we needed and used. I feel like if we had never had that retarded cevo vs esea shitstorm that happend before the season began this game might have had atleast another year couple years or atleast would have made us a bit stronger as a community.
This this this.
I feel the ESEA-CEVO split caused a lot more harm than people realize, and it really hurts me to say it knowing how much time TheFragile, Lange, Nahanni and countless others put into it to make it happen. The split separated our small communities into even smaller communities. Neither league was really as competitive as it would have been if one just died and the other survived.
Some numbers (ESEA Season on left, number of teams across all TF2 divisions on right):
S10 | 68
S11 | 83
S12 | 68
S13 | 89
S14 | 102
S15 | 85
S16 | 52
S17 | 63
S14 was the highest in terms of registration. Shortly before S14 began, the bitcoin fiasco occurred. S15 was when ESEA added the "Main" division to TF2 due to its growth the previous year, and an extra team in invite. The first time TF2 ever had the Main division. A lot of people argued it would make the game more competitively balanced and I'm inclined to agree. With more teams, you need more divisions so that you can play against similarly skilled opponents. Nobody wants to get rolled week after week. Good things are happening, finally TF2 is getting some of the things CS has had for awhile in ESEA. I'm also pretty sure the TF2 prize pot increased substantially to allow the fourth place team to come away with a small profit. It wasn't much, but before this point, every season we'd have LAN fundraisers, similar to our fundraisers for the the i-series LANs, to get 4th, 3rd, and sometimes 2nd and 1st place teams to LAN.
Then CEVO introduces its TF2 division and lots of people switch leagues due to ESEA's lackluster TF2 support. CEVO seemed to be a great, almost community driven league that didn't come with all the stuff we paid for (but didn't use) in ESEA. The downside? It's smaller in scope and potential. A reliable LAN wasn't guaranteed. Even if there were LANs, they wouldn't pay back travel expenses, and it wouldn't be as highly regarded as ESEA for the simple fact that it hasn't been serious competition for ESEA in years. ESEA at this point has an international LAN. People fly from France to play in its LAN event, and we're splitting our numbers with a league that might not even have a LAN every year?
I'm not defending ESEA at all for their lack of support for competitive TF2. There are times when their support has been dodgy at best. However, they have always kept TF2 in their league, even two seasons after the huge dip in numbers shown above. They finally gave us a Main division and a balanced 9 team invite. The very next season we dump all that progress we as a community made in ESEA because they did something really stupid that didn't even affect the TF2 community nearly as much as it did the CS community, which relies heavily on the bitcoin-mining client.
After that season I took a break from TF2, partly forced due to real life, but also partly because I knew how bad it would be in both CEVO and ESEA in terms of numbers. Now CEVO is not having another TF2 season, and I don't blame them with the numbers they got (although starting a season in the middle of the holidays is a questionable business move).
The only thing that I think will keep TF2 alive is if the community realizes that ESEA is the best we got, and we have to stick with it if we want a competitive environment. ESEA LAN generates views, interest, its something to talk about and watch as a community. ESEA pays TFTV's production crew for their work so it doesn't seem like a complete waste of time for them to fly over. They have the best CS players in the world in the same building, and that comes with sponsors, money, and recognition.
We don't have the resources or players to be split between two leagues, and I think CEVO letting TF2 go will reunite the TF2 community again if we're all willing to accept what little we have and make the best of it. We'll see what happens from there.