Just keep the current rotation, don't vote out gpit or gully and then vote in something that no one has played and ends up being a complete shitfest. We got lucky with metalworks this season.

It hasn't, it's in for the upcoming OWL season in round 3 and 6

http://ozfortress.com/showthread.php?t=57239

What do you guys think of Koth Arctic and Koth flake? I think they deserve consideration

Add Artic, or any other KOTH map.

When cp_edifice is done, add that.

http://forums.tf2maps.net/showthread.php?t=20891 (a map to try?)

Meh, arctic. Not a very good 6v6 map imo. Pushing the point is a shitfest.

Warmfront= Best Roaming Middle in TF2.

I didn't mind metalworks. Would pick over warmfront, anyway

instead of making entirely new maps we should just fix the ones that have issues.

warmfront was good except last, same goes for yukon

I'd like a change of scenery.

If Yukon gets voted back in I will shut down the entire Internet.

On a serious note I'm with panzer about freight and well. Personally freight was one of my favorite maps before valve picked up the final version (which was shit) as an official map. I'd love to see like cp_freight_classic with the oldschool layout. Also... cp_well_pro

Someone needs to make this. Back in the day when granary had those stupid gates we made a version without them. I'd love to see a pro version of well without gates, and hopefully a smaller last point (it's way too open and big).

Is it possible to make standin like a gpit map where 1 team tries to cap all 3 points, instead of all 3 going simultaneously. Would also be easier to cast that way. That super long revert time kills standin as it is.

fix last on yukon and it will be a top 3 fav for me...

mid on yukon is shit too. 2nd point is decent, but mid and last are horrible.

I think Yukon's mid is kind of fun

whatever happened to cp_foundry

current map list wasn't too bad. would like to see a better koth map replace viaduct and a better attack/defend map replace gpit though.

cp_quay

Though I didn't technically play any matches on metalworks (but I did scrim it a bunch), metalworks isn't very good imo. The spawns were too long, the last point sucked, and the second point needs to be reworked.

I never thought yukon or warmfront were too bad. The last points were kinda meh, but I think metalworks has more problems than yukon and warmfront.

I haven't had a chance to check out edifice, but I think we should consider that because a lot of the problems with gpit seem to be fixed now. The fixed-spawns version of granary should definitely be used as well.

My vote lies against metalworks and for Warmfront

Although Yukon would be my second choice.

I didn't like metalworks because of its weird chokey architecture from mid to 2, and all the twisty turney rooms headed into last. I see what was being attempted - a valley like in blands = flank, but unfortunately that area is simply too big.

Warmfront is a fine map, and although last can be rough, it's not impossible by any stretch of the imagination. Yukon is a little harder because of height problems and the pipe thingey + mid fights are really weird.

What makes pushing warmfront last so hard?

cp_mainline_rc5 (the one double natasha heavy ruined)

or

cp_mainline_rc6 (the one he edited to the tune of everyones criticism but a worse version, imo)

take a look at them, I dare you

i thought the map pool was pretty decent. metalworks didnt seem terrible enough to warrant removal. I think it would be ideal to add another map to either the A/D or koth game modes so that they become more common. whether there is such a map that would be worthy of such a position i dont know.

I'm surprised to see this much support for warmfront. People did nothing but complain when it was in. IIRC it got >50% of the vote for having it taken out of the map pool S11 or whatever it was.

Recently played Mainline RC6 in Bosh PUGs. It was pretty fun IMO and the map is aesthetically pleasing. PUGs are a poor way of evaluating a map but Mainline PUGs >>> Metalworks PUGs.